Catered All The Way Book Review By Annabeth Albert

When I say books should come with a emotional warning I’m not going to lie, thing is this book should have had one at the start of every chapter it was so darn good and emotional! I couldn’t wait to write a review about it and review it online!

I’ve read a few books from Annabeth Albert so far and will say that she is consistent in her writing and they are always highly rated for me. After reading The Geek Who Saved Christmas I couldn’t wait to read Catered All The Way and I’m so glad I did, it’s a festive read you shouldn’t pass by!

All spoilers will be marked in italics so if you haven’t read the book try and avoid them as I’d hate to spoil it for you as it’s so good!!

Catered All The Way Book Tropes

Take a look at some of the book tropes that Catered All The Way by Annabeth Albert would fit into.

• Brother’s Best Friend – The protagonist falls for his older brother’s best friend, adding layers of familiarity, history, and a touch of forbidden romance.
• Forced Proximity – Sharing a small living space (and eventually a bed) brings the characters closer together, igniting romantic tension.
• There’s Only One Bed – A classic trope that forces intimacy and challenges boundaries.
• Grumpy/Sunshine Dynamic – One character (Atlas) is steady and reserved, while the other (the narrator) is upbeat and charmingly chaotic.
• First-Time Exploration – Atlas has never been with a guy, creating a subplot of discovery and vulnerability as he navigates new territory.
• Holiday Romance – The story is infused with festive cheer, from snowball fights to family traditions, creating a cosy, heartwarming setting.
• Workplace Romance – As co-workers, the characters must balance their budding relationship with professional responsibilities.
• Small-Town Charm – The setting, Kringle’s Crossing, is brimming with holiday magic and tight-knit community vibes.
• Slow Burn to Steamy – The romance builds gradually, with flirty moments and growing emotional connection before culminating in sizzling passion.
• Happily Ever After Potential – The emotional stakes are high, with themes of compromise, belonging, and building a future together.

Catered All The Way Synopsis

Tis the season for falling head over heels for my older brother’s best friend…

This year, things are going to be different. I’m not the shy, awkward kid I used to be. My gaming channel is thriving, my confidence is at an all-time high, and I’m finally ready to make a move on Atlas Orion—the impossibly gorgeous Navy chief I’ve been crushing on for as long as I can remember.

But spilling cranberry sauce all over him? Not exactly the grand reintroduction I had in mind.

Atlas is back in town to help save Seasons, my family’s cherished holiday gift shop and event venue. With back-to-back catered events on the schedule, there’s no room for any more slip-ups—especially when I’m stuck sharing a room (and eventually a bed) with the man who stars in every one of my daydreams.

Atlas has never been with a guy before, but it doesn’t take much convincing to spark a secret holiday fling. No strings, no expectations—just two guys exploring something new. But as the weeks pass, the lines blur. Atlas isn’t just a walking dreamboat with a heroic career; he’s thoughtful, funny, and somehow makes burnt toast taste like a gourmet breakfast. Midnight snowball fights, cozy movie nights—it all feels too perfect to be temporary.

Yet the reality looms: Atlas can’t stay in Kringle’s Crossing forever, and I can’t imagine leaving the only place I’ve ever called home. As our feelings deepen, I can’t help but wonder—is this just a holiday fantasy? Or could we turn this spark into something that lasts beyond the season?

Buy Catered All The Way

Want this read this festive masterpiece? Click on the button below and you can buy Catered All The Way by Annabeth Albert!

Catered All The Way Book Review

The synopsis makes it sound a little boring and obvious but honestly, I did not think that. My heart was being pulled into so many directions I had no idea how they were going to solve the big issue! Take a look at my Catered All The Way review and let me know if you agree with me!

Catered All The Way Book Rating – 4.5/5

I would love to know what you thought about my rating, do you agree with me, disagree with me or think I hit the nail on the head? I thought the book was festive magic, it had snow, hot guys, bi-awakenings and so much more! It’s one of the books I wish I could read again for the first time and cry all over again!

Catered All The Way Plot – 4

The plot was so easy to follow, there were no complicated twists or words that tripped you up and it flowed with ease. I loved how gripping and captivating it was and it really embodied Christmas as well with snow, snowball fights and more!

SPOILERS The only thing I’d have liked more rom the plot would be to see some more reactions of them “coming out” or more people taking notice of them. However, it was a really good plot and meant I could speed through it!

Catered All The Way Characters – 5

I can’t fault any of the Characters which is very weird for me. They were all well described so it was easy to build a picture in my mind. They all had their role and they all made the book something special. I’d love to know if anyone had any objections with the characters so that I could take another look and see but I can’t fault them.

Catered All The Way Emotional Factor – 5

Annabeth Albert should be paying my therapy bills for the next couple of sessions. The emotions were off the charts. I was crying so hard I had to stop reading, smiling so much my jaw hurt and cheering to the point my husband came downstairs to ask if I was okay!

SPOILER! Honest to every god there is, when Atlas left Zeb in that car I couldn’t stop crying, I had to walk away from the book and compose myself before I could carry on reading. That chapter took my heart and threw it around a basketball court. It was so well written, so gut wrenching and just epic. Also, the Christmas tree decoration had me in a whole new flood of tears!

Catered All The Way Ending -4

I normally hate endings but this one wrapped everything together and the season’s family all helped bring it to a close nicely. There were no pressing unanswered questions which is always nice as well. As far as endings go, this was a good one.

SPOILERS When Atlas proposed my heart melted, however, I would have liked to have read about the wedding as well but it cut off on Christmas day. It was still a good ending but that would be the only thing in my mind.

Catered All The Way Spice Factor – 3

I don’t include spice in the overall ratings of books but I like to talk about it, it isn’t in all books which is why I don’t include it. Catered All The Way by Annabeth Albert had spice throughout and honestly, it was pretty hot, it wasn’t too in your face and it was put in exactly where you’d expect it to be.

SPOILERS When Zeb offered to have sex with Atlas that’s when you knew it was going to pick up! I loved how Zeb went from this worried persona to, let’s just bang okay! His confidence shone through and I loved how Atlas brought out that naughty side in him even with his bi-awakening.

Get Your Copy